Does the Bible and Christian teaching entitle everyone to health care? It seems like a straightforward question, but the responses are anything but.
President Barack Obama’s administration has unveiled a plan for health care in the U.S. that, more or less, calls for the creation of a government-run, publically funded insurance company, or a “public option.” Some religious groups, including Faith in Public Life, Faithful America, the PICO National Network and Catholics in Alliance for the Common Good, have teamed up to purchase radio advertisements encouraging pastors to get behind the proposed health care reform. The ads frame health care as a moral issue and discuss the human right to health care.
On the other hand, many churches and their leaders are steering clear of this political issue. The argument pits emotional and ethical rhetoric (pathos and ethos) against pragmatism and logic (logos) – a battle that cannot be won on either side. For every good point one might make about why the proposed overhaul of health care and health insurance is a good idea, someone can make an equally valid counterpoint, most notably the exorbitant cost of the program. The questions are seemingly endless: What will happen to the quality of care? Will citizens and doctors still have choices? Would the government-run company provide care for all? What will happen to taxes? Will the current private insurance survive and if not, what economic impact would that have?
Beyond the biblical and ethical questions surrounding a massive government overhaul of health care, what implications would such as a change have for you as an employer and staff manager? Would you support a system where you don’t have to pay for employee’s benefits because health care is socialized? Could you afford to offer health benefits if you knew a public option existed?
I’m curious where our readers stand, as this issue is currently at the forefront of domestic policy.
Wondering how you feel about the solution on the table,
John
Sources:
Yahoo News: Religious Group’s Radio Ads Back Health Care Overhaul
MyFox8.com: Obama’s Health Care Plan
Related Content:
Control the Cost
Will the Stimulus Weaken the Church?